What is Shari'ah Law? Understanding the Divine Path in Islam
What is islamic law?
Islamic
law i.e. shariah is the divine law or divine will of almighty Allah revealed to
Prophet Muhammad {saw} the last and final messenger in the latest and most
perfect form. According to traditional Muslim beliefs, the word of God is law, and law
is God's order. This law is known as sharia. Fiqh, which is the jurisprudence in
character, is the ascertainment of the right principle. In the word of God is
included, of course, the Quran, but the divinely inspired sunnah of the prophet
ranks equal. These two are immutable and the only room for the exercise of
human reason is in their understanding. These two sources, namely, the Quran and
the sunnah may thus be said to form the fundamental roots of Islamic law. The
word shariah itself is derived etymologically
forms a root meaning “road”. It is the path that leads to God, the concrete
manifestation of the divine will through which man should live his individual
and social lives. The most profound cause for the necessity for revelation is
the presence of impediments in man's intelligence that limit its concerted
functioning.
The proper conception of law requires a complete perception of the earth for
all time to come, and the type of human life hereafter. The main trouble with
the man is that he cannot have before him the complete picture of human life and
nature.In the word of Kant, perception without conception is empty. For muslims
the source of the law is revelation because it is for almighty Allah alone to
know with precision what rules of conduct are most expedient for the majority
of humanity in his world. Islam law was the most far-reaching and successful
force in shaping the social order and community life of the Muslim people. By its very comprehensiveness,
it exerts the steady pressure upon all private and social activities, setting a
standard to which they conformed more closely as time went on, in spite of the resistance
of ancient habits and time honoured customs, especially amongst the more independent
nomadic and mountain tribes. Moreover, Islamic law gave practical expression to
the characteristics muslim quest for unity. In all essentials it was uniform,
although the various schools differed in points of details The Muslim scholars did not
consider law to be an autonomous or empirical subject. Mohammad {saw}'s
religious and social theory had no separation between legal and religious
aspects, making it practical for early Muslims. The two aspects are found side
by side, or rather interlaced, in the Quran, as well as in the Hadith.
The divine law is analogous to a network of injunctions and attitudes that
control all aspects of human existence and, in their whole and all-encompassing
nature, are capable of integrating man and society in accordance with Islam's
guiding ideal, unity or Tawhid. In Islam, law is an intrinsic part of the
revelation rather than an foreign element. According to the Islamic belief,
religions should not be modified to conform to the ever-changing and imperfect
nature of men; rather, persons should reform in order to live according to the tenants
of revelations. Holy Quran is the fundamental source of revelation and Prophetic
tradition and practices the second at the starting point.
What is Muslim Law
Muslim law, often referred to as Shariah or Islamic law, governs the lives of Muslims in various aspects including religious practices, social behavior, personal conduct, marriage, inheritance, and criminal justice. Derived from the Qur’an (the holy book of Islam), Hadith (sayings and actions of Prophet Muhammad), Ijma (consensus of scholars), and Qiyas (analogy), Muslim law provides a comprehensive framework that regulates not only the relationship between an individual and their faith but also between individuals in a community. The practice of Muslim law varies across regions due to different interpretations and schools of thought.
1. Sources of Muslim Law
The primary sources of Muslim law are:
The Qur'an: The central religious text of Islam, believed by Muslims to be the literal word of God as revealed to Prophet Muhammad. It is the supreme authority in Islamic jurisprudence.
The Hadith: This consists of the sayings, actions, and tacit approvals of Prophet Muhammad. Hadith supplements the Qur'an and offers detailed guidance on the interpretation and application of Islamic principles.
Ijma: This refers to the consensus of Islamic scholars on a particular issue. It plays a crucial role in addressing contemporary issues not directly covered in the Qur'an or Hadith.
Qiyas: This is the use of analogy to derive legal principles. When the Qur'an and Hadith do not directly address a situation, scholars use qiyas to apply a principle from similar circumstances.
Ijtihad: Independent reasoning or effort by scholars to interpret the law in light of contemporary issues. Ijtihad is essential for evolving interpretations as society progresses.
2. Key Aspects of Muslim Law
Muslim law covers various spheres of life, including:
Family Law: One of the most significant branches, including marriage, divorce, and inheritance. Under Muslim law, marriage is viewed as a contract (Nikah) and divorce (Talaq) can be initiated by either party, with specific regulations governing both. Inheritance laws are based on fixed shares as prescribed in the Qur'an.
Criminal Law: Muslim criminal law covers offenses like theft (Hadd), adultery (Zina), apostasy, and defamation (Qadhf). The penalties for these crimes are severe but are tempered by the requirement for strong evidence, particularly in the case of hadd offenses.
Contractual Law: Islamic law governs contracts, including buying and selling, partnerships, and financial transactions. The prohibition of interest (Riba) is one of the core principles in Islamic finance.
Personal Law: This includes laws concerning personal status such as the dress code, dietary restrictions, and daily rituals prescribed for Muslims.
3. Schools of Thought in Muslim Law
There are four major Sunni schools of thought, which differ slightly in their interpretations of Islamic law. These are:
Hanafi: The largest and most widely followed school, particularly in South Asia, Turkey, and the Balkans.
Maliki: Predominantly followed in North and West Africa.
Shafi’i: Common in East Africa, Southeast Asia, and parts of the Arabian Peninsula.
Hanbali: Found primarily in Saudi Arabia and some parts of the Arabian Peninsula.
Additionally, there are Shia schools of thought, with the Ja'fari school being the most prominent, particularly in Iran and parts of Iraq and Lebanon.
4. Role of Islamic Courts
Muslim countries have varying degrees of reliance on Islamic courts. Some countries apply Islamic law in a secular context, while others adopt it fully for personal matters such as family law and inheritance. In more conservative nations, Islamic law might extend to criminal law as well.
Difference Between Islamic Law and Muslim Law
Although the terms Islamic law and Muslim law are often used interchangeably, they can have distinct meanings based on context. The distinction arises when considering the historical and geographical spread of Islamic jurisprudence.
1. Islamic Law
Scope: Islamic law is a broader term, encompassing the entire body of legal principles derived from the Qur'an, Hadith, and the consensus of Islamic scholars. It extends beyond personal matters into public law, governance, criminal law, and international relations.
Ideal Implementation: Islamic law, in its purest sense, is meant to be implemented as a comprehensive system governing not just individuals but the state and society as a whole. In Islamic governance, the ruler or the state is expected to enforce Islamic law, encompassing all aspects of governance, economics, and social order.
Historical Context: Historically, Islamic law was fully implemented in Islamic caliphates such as the Rashidun, Umayyad, and Abbasid caliphates. It also influenced the legal systems of countries such as Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Iran.
Global Influence: Islamic law has had significant global influence, especially in regions with Muslim-majority populations, and is seen as a universal system of justice and ethical governance.
2. Muslim Law
Scope: Muslim law refers more specifically to the aspects of Islamic law that apply to Muslims within a given state or jurisdiction, particularly regarding personal and family matters. It is often a subset of Islamic law, focusing on rules governing marriage, divorce, inheritance, and other personal rights.
State Implementation: Unlike Islamic law, which theoretically applies to all aspects of governance, Muslim law is often confined to personal law within a country, with secular laws governing criminal law and public matters.
Regional Variations: Muslim law is often influenced by the legal frameworks of the countries where Muslims live. For instance, in India, Muslim law is governed by the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937, while in Pakistan, family law issues for Muslims are governed by the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961. These laws allow for religious freedom and the application of Muslim personal law while still recognizing the primacy of state law.
Modern Context: In many non-Muslim majority countries, Muslim law is applied primarily to personal matters, often through religious courts or family law courts.
Scope of Muslim Law in India:
Muslim law in India operates primarily within the realm of personal law, focusing on the legal aspects related to marriage, divorce, inheritance, and other family matters among Muslims. India, as a secular country with a pluralistic society, allows its citizens to follow personal laws based on their religious beliefs. Consequently, Muslim law in India is governed by a mix of Islamic law (Shariah), statutory laws, and judicial interpretations. Despite its religious roots, Muslim law is applied in India within the framework of the Indian legal system.
Here, we will explore the scope of Muslim law in India in-depth, addressing the key areas where it governs, the laws that apply to Muslims, and the influence of Islamic jurisprudence in the Indian legal context.
1. Constitutional Framework and Secularism
India is a secular state, meaning that it does not endorse any particular religion. The Constitution of India guarantees equality before the law, and Article 44 of the Directive Principles of State Policy calls for the state to endeavor to secure a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) for all its citizens. However, the Indian Constitution recognizes the right of religious communities to govern their personal laws, which allows Muslims in India to follow their religious laws in matters of family, marriage, inheritance, and similar personal affairs.
Thus, Muslim law is applied primarily in the context of personal law and family matters, but it operates within the broader framework of Indian constitutional principles. The state ensures that personal laws do not violate constitutional provisions such as the right to equality, non-discrimination, and the protection of fundamental rights.
2. Sources of Muslim Law in India
In India, Muslim law is not codified entirely in one statute. Instead, it is a mixture of Islamic principles and local statutory laws. The primary sources of Muslim law in India are:
The Qur'an and Hadith: These religious texts are the foundational sources of Muslim law. The Qur'an is the divine scripture, while the Hadith consists of the sayings and actions of Prophet Muhammad. These sources provide the core legal framework for family and personal laws.
The Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937: This is a key statute that applies Muslim personal law to matters of marriage, inheritance, and other family issues among Muslims. It allows Muslims in India to follow Islamic personal law in their private affairs, overriding other civil laws that might apply in similar situations.
The Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939: This act governs the dissolution of marriage (divorce) among Muslims in India. It provides a statutory procedure for Muslim women to obtain a divorce, thus addressing some of the issues related to gender equality within Islamic divorce law.
The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986: This Act came into being after the controversial Shah Bano case (1985). It aims to protect the rights of Muslim women in the event of divorce, ensuring alimony and financial support after the dissolution of marriage.
Judicial Interpretations: The Indian judiciary has played a significant role in shaping the scope of Muslim law. Judicial rulings often interpret and adapt Muslim law to the evolving societal context, especially in matters of gender equality and women’s rights.
3. Family Law and Personal Status
Muslim law in India governs various aspects of family life. The key areas under Muslim law are:
a. Marriage (Nikah)
In Muslim law, marriage is considered a contract (Nikah) between a man and a woman, not a sacrament as in some other religions. It is based on mutual consent and requires witnesses to be valid. The marriage contract outlines the rights and responsibilities of both parties.
Mahr (Dower): One of the key elements of a Muslim marriage is the payment of mahr (dower) by the husband to the wife, which is her right. It serves as a form of financial security for the wife.
Conditions of Marriage: The marriage must meet certain conditions for it to be valid under Muslim law, including the consent of both parties and the presence of witnesses.
Polygamy: Muslim law permits polygamy, allowing a Muslim man to have up to four wives, provided he treats them equally. However, this practice is controversial, and certain Indian states have put restrictions on polygamy.
b. Divorce (Talaq)
Divorce under Muslim law can be initiated by both the husband and wife, but the procedures differ:
Talaq (Divorce by Husband): This is the most common form of divorce in Islamic law. The husband can divorce his wife by pronouncing the word talaq three times, though recent reforms have limited the practice of talaq by the enactment of the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986, which requires the husband to provide maintenance to the wife after divorce.
Talaq-e-Biddat (Triple Talaq): The practice of talaq pronounced three times in one sitting has been controversial and was deemed unconstitutional by the Indian Supreme Court in 2017 in the landmark case of Shayara Bano v. Union of India. The practice was banned as it was deemed to violate the rights of women.
Khula (Divorce by Wife): A woman can initiate divorce under Muslim law by seeking khula, where she petitions the court to annul the marriage. The woman must return the mahr (dower) to the husband for the divorce to be effective.
c. Maintenance and Alimony
Muslim law provides for maintenance during marriage and after divorce. The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986 ensures that Muslim women are entitled to maintenance for a reasonable period after divorce. The amount is decided based on the husband's financial condition.
d. Inheritance and Succession
One of the most significant areas of Muslim law is the regulation of inheritance. Islamic law of inheritance is strictly outlined in the Qur'an and divides the property among the heirs based on fixed shares.
Share of Heirs: In Muslim law, the heirs' shares are fixed, with male heirs generally receiving double the share of female heirs. The primary heirs are the children, spouses, parents, and siblings of the deceased.
Will (Wasiyyah): A Muslim can make a will to distribute up to one-third of their property to non-heirs, but the remainder must be distributed according to the fixed shares outlined in the Qur'an.
4. Statutory Laws Influencing Muslim Law in India
In addition to Islamic principles, several statutory laws have shaped the scope of Muslim law in India:
The Special Marriage Act, 1954: This Act allows for a civil marriage between Muslims and non-Muslims or between Muslims who do not wish to follow the Muslim personal law for marriage. The Act provides a secular alternative to religious marriages and governs the divorce and maintenance of couples married under it.
The Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860: The IPC governs criminal law in India. While Islamic criminal law (Hadd offenses) may not be directly applied, Muslim individuals are still subject to the general criminal law of India, which covers offenses like theft, assault, and defamation.
The Indian Evidence Act, 1872: This law governs the admissibility of evidence in Indian courts. Muslim law operates alongside the Indian Evidence Act, meaning that evidence in Muslim law matters (e.g., marriage, divorce, inheritance) must adhere to its provisions.
5. Role of Courts and Judicial Interpretation
The role of Indian courts is crucial in the interpretation and application of Muslim law. Courts act as arbiters in disputes involving Muslim personal law, interpreting it in light of constitutional principles. The judiciary has been instrumental in promoting gender equality and addressing the challenges posed by outdated practices, such as triple talaq.
The Indian judiciary has often struck a balance between maintaining Islamic principles and upholding constitutional rights. Landmark judgments, such as those in the Shah Bano case (1985), Shayara Bano case (2017), and Sardar Ali case (2001), have reshaped the application of Muslim law in India.
6. Challenges and Reforms
Despite the recognition of Muslim personal law, there are several challenges:
Gender Inequality: Muslim law has been criticized for its unequal treatment of women, especially in matters of divorce and inheritance. Although the courts have taken steps to protect women's rights, the reform of personal laws remains a contentious issue.
Uniform Civil Code (UCC): There has been ongoing debate regarding the implementation of a Uniform Civil Code that would replace personal laws for all communities. While some support the UCC for ensuring equality, others argue that it would infringe upon the religious rights of communities, including Muslims.
Modernization: The need to modernize Muslim law to address contemporary issues, such as the status of women and child custody, remains an ongoing challenge.
Related posts
what is will and rules of will